MBA or not to MBA


Jump to Page:
< Previous  [ 1 ]  [ 2 ]  [ 3 ]    Next >



jago_desi   
Member since: Sep 04
Posts: 591
Location: canada

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 17-02-05 13:03:44

Quote:
Orginally posted by DiogenestheCynic

Even if you graduate from Harvard or Yale, it is not "guaranteed" that you will get what you want.



I would like to add to this comment.
There is a TV show here... The Apprentice (It is aired in India too?) ...by Donald Trump (multi billioner of US).....Show is made of live case studies given to top MBA's from Havard / Yale ...... And Mr. Trump judges a person by their personal performance and not college from where student graduated....on that show he has fired students from these top institutes too and appreciated students from lesser known colleges....no institue will guarantee job......it is your creativity


-----------------------------------------------------------------
Try overtaking child's imagination


Skywalker   
Member since: Aug 04
Posts: 91
Location: Oakville

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 17-02-05 14:16:48

A local MBA would deffinately give you an edge over the rest when hunting for a job ..... then again like any good MBA programme ..... it all depends where you get the MBA from ....... the top three programes have a reputation of job offers to their graduating Alumni before they graduate ....

The Private sector keeps an eye on the top four sessions .... they go by different means e.g. study papers .... internships .... case studies etc etc etc and they evaluate thru the Prof's input .... usually they look for the following ...
1) Confidence
2) Communication Skills
3) Salesmanship
4) Skill

in this particular order too ....

If it helps you a bit ..... Asians tend to be far more competitive .... If you have a decent international exposeure thru your previous job ... it would help ...... but then the more aggressive way to go about it is build a network while you are in the University ..... Statistacaly .. the top 3% jobs are never advertised and go by networking .... It is not WHAT you know ... it is WHO you know ....

Ivey league .... University of Western Ontario
Queens's
Rotman .... U of Toronto

These Universities have a very strong Alumni base .... becoming a part of either one of these would give you a boost which no other head hunter would offer.

Best of Luck


-----------------------------------------------------------------
When the Axe entered the forest ... the trees cried out ..... It is the Handle that is one of us.
Rumi


natehc   
Member since: Feb 05
Posts: 24
Location:

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 18-02-05 12:54:31

All i can say is all prospective immigrants are not "another brick in the wall kind of people".

My friend who is immigrating is a 1st class honors Engineer from a Mumbai university, has 5 years work experience in india in the top 5 of the fortune 500 companies and presently works as a project manager without a MBA. He makes 8 lakhs in india and he is moving. Obviously to hold such position and work with clients in the US he has to have good if not exceptional communication skills. He can get CIO recommendations from US
I applied for immigration with him (it was his idea and i liked it, and we more or less faced the same processing times) and i may not be as sucessful as he is in india but i think if someone like him does not get into a MBA school then who will?

I feel with or without MBA he will have more chances of sucess than "just another immigrant"

He has more or less decided on a MBA, for me as i am a Techie and not a manager i am still thinking....if it will help...

Also i have worked with ISB/IIM MBA's and i ask then what do they learn in 1 year in ISB that takes their salary from 3-4l py in India to minimum of 9-10l py. Do they run magic wand on them

My friend said its nothing specail...They make you understand management concepts and work very hard...Its the brand value that counts most of the time...Unlike Mr Trump most organizations want to hire branded people from these schools..these people are good...but are not born with horns over their head.....A little hard work gets you long way...is what they say.....

Comments welcome



jago_desi   
Member since: Sep 04
Posts: 591
Location: canada

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 18-02-05 13:46:54

Quote:
Orginally posted by natehc

Unlike Mr Trump most organizations want to hire branded people from these schools..these people are good...but are not born with horns over their head.....A little hard work gets you long way...is what they say.....



Mention of Mr Trump, the recent episodes aired in Canada are of Univ. Gradutes vs Street Smart (no college) and guess what.....street smart have given ride episode after episode to Univ. Grad.
It is not just the school this man looks at, same may be true for other Mr Trump's lesser known to world.
You may get hired for the Univ. Brand name but for sure you get fired for your Capablities & attitude.


-----------------------------------------------------------------
Try overtaking child's imagination


natehc   
Member since: Feb 05
Posts: 24
Location:

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 18-02-05 13:51:08

Totally agree with you there....MBA can be your ticket to move up but once there you need to maintain yourself (by politics, hard work or whatever works)

Sometimes the more difficult part is getting there and not staying there



natehc   
Member since: Feb 05
Posts: 24
Location:

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 18-02-05 13:51:08

Totally agree with you there....MBA can be your ticket to move up but once there you need to maintain yourself (by politics, hard work or whatever works)

Sometimes the more difficult part is getting there and not staying there



Skywalker   
Member since: Aug 04
Posts: 91
Location: Oakville

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 18-02-05 15:05:04



Gentlemen ..... keep one thing in mind .... Trump's programme is a reality show .... it has been scripted for viewer ratings only ..... not much to do with reality .... deriving ques from such a programme for your future base in another country is a very dangerous thing to do ..... you are setting yourself up for disappointment ...


Another hard reality is .... in the GTA ..... you'll bump into a lot of engineers driving cabs and other above minimum wage jobs .... I personnaly have known a few of them .... a lot of these highlu accomplished individuals get caught in these situations where out of embarrassment and fear of being called a loser do not return to the "Middle East" or their countries of their origin where they had previously managed to prove their metle ......

I would think twice if I were your engineer frined who plans to come to Canada .... plan for the worse .... keep your priorities right ......


-----------------------------------------------------------------
When the Axe entered the forest ... the trees cried out ..... It is the Handle that is one of us.
Rumi


Contributors: natehc(5) jago_desi(4) DiogenestheCynic(2) Skywalker(2) nmt(1) dfwrp(1)



Jump to Page: < Previous  [ 1 ]  [ 2 ]  [ 3 ]    Next >

Discussions similar to: MBA or not to MBA

Topic Forum Views Replies
Which on is top most university of Canada? ( 1 2 )
Study 5470 10
difference between post-graduate and under-graduate degree?
Study 2067 2
A TV SERIAL FOR DESIS
Arts and Culture 3008 3
Anybody going to a community college ??
Study 2047 1
THE FASTEST THING
Have Fun! 1593 0
Graduate Studies
Study 1817 0
Doctor of Business Administration (DBA) programs in Canada
Study 10257 2
Tatas' $50-million gift to Harvard, largest from an international donor
Our Native Country! 2465 4
Delay in applying for Post graduate work permit
Student Visa 2491 0
Post graduate work permit
Independent Category 1580 1
Missed the last date for Post graduate work permit
Ask Immigration Expert 1815 2
Yale Varsity turns Indian MPs into students
Our Native Country! 1432 0
Harvard cancels Subramanian Swamy's courses. ( 1 2 3 4 )
USA 5052 21
Environmental control
Study 1701 2
Bahu ka Degree; Chala Yale Khaya Bhel !
Have Fun! 1084 0
Will Hillary reach White House?
USA 2856 6
Presidential debate last night
USA 2139 1
Donald Trump
USA 3013 5
Muslim prayer issue reaches boiling point at Peel board meeting ( 1 2 3 ... Last )
General 17901 106
USA Borders are TIGHT !
General 1776 4
TRUMP & MODI VERSUS TRUDEAU
General 1325 1
Say Good Bye to USA Immigration!
General 1571 1
YOU MAY NEED TO PROVIDE THE PASSWORDS FOR SOCIAL MEDIA FOR "US" VISA
General 1509 2
This is the proof that Trump is only against radical Islam ( 1 2 )
General 1846 8
Will TN Visa go along with NAFTA ?
USA and other countries 2397 1
 


Share:
















Advertise Contact Us Privacy Policy and Terms of Usage FAQ
Canadian Desi
© 2001 Marg eSolutions


Site designed, developed and maintained by Marg eSolutions Inc.