Sachin Vs Punter - Who is the best?


Jump to Page:
< Previous  [ 1 ]  [ 2 ]    Next >



DesiBabu70   
Member since: Feb 04
Posts: 213
Location: St. Catherines ON

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 20-01-10 13:30:47

You are right. Kallis is an awesome player. Not as glamorous and controversial as Ponting but a better player.
He's the one who has kept South Africa batting together.
On his best days, Brian Lara is perhaps indestructible esp. on a fast paced pitch like West Indies, South Africa or England.
I saw him play in the West Indies during his peak times and he was classical.
No one can beat his style on his best day.
But he doesn't have consistency, temperament and down to ground attitude that Tendulkar has.
Brian got cocky, spoilt and began to think he was above the game.
Pride goeth before a fall, and he made a slow, lacklustre and forgettable exit from the game.



mumdxbcan   
Member since: Jul 07
Posts: 469
Location:

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 20-01-10 14:40:14

If we don't go by figures, certainly Ponting is way ahead with respect to Tendulkar

Please see link
http://stats.cricinfo.com/ci/content/current/records/282976.html

Tendulkar is not even in the list

Ponting / Lara two times

Even Class wise Dravid far better than Tendulkar

Dravid too in the list



DesiBabu70   
Member since: Feb 04
Posts: 213
Location: St. Catherines ON

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 20-01-10 15:09:20

Quote:
Originally posted by mumdxbcan
Please see link
http://stats.cricinfo.com/ci/content/current/records/282976.html

Tendulkar is not even in the list

Ponting / Lara two times

Even Class wise Dravid far better than Tendulkar

Dravid too in the list

That is a list for hundreds in consecutive matches.
That doesn't prove anything.
There are names on that list that are nobodies when compared to great batsmen past and present.
IMO, Dravid has been more consistent compared to Tendulkar.
Tendulkar has this tendency of giving away his wicket at the most crucial times when the team needs his most; and sometimes he gives away his wicket is silly manner that is not becoming of a batsman who is often compared to Bradman.
Dravid on the other hand has the opposite tendency he guards his wicket well and usually sticks around when needed most.
that said, Tendulkar's range of shots, class and ability is better than Dravid's.
It's like Chanderpaul and Lara to some extent.
Lara has more ability and better class than Chanderpaul yet Chanderpaul has served his team in very crucial times when none of the other top batsmen did.





Jump to Page: < Previous  [ 1 ]  [ 2 ]    Next >

Discussions similar to: Sachin Vs Punter - Who is the best?

Topic Forum Views Replies
Pravasi Bharatiya Divas and Dual Citizenship
Our Native Country! 2649 5
Hindi TV channels
Life 4441 6
Can Kenya reach super-six?
Sports 1972 4
Social Club for South Asian Girls and Women in Toronto - Please check it out
News and Events 2008 0
Social Club for South Asian Girls and Women in Toronto
Life 1872 0
Return of the Jedi (aka West Indies Cricket) ( 1 2 )
Sports 2217 7
Important information in Job Section of this site ( 1 2 )
Life 3701 11
Canada qualifies for 2007 Cricket World Cup
Sports 1690 3
New ones ( 1 2 )
Have Fun! 2596 7
Shouldn't Sachin Tendulkar Retire ?
Sports 2100 5
Antigua Test : West Indies v/s India Drawn Match
Sports 1639 0
Possible Indo-Pak clash on April 1
Sports 1427 4
Hi from South Africa!
Moving Soon 1600 1
Driving direction from Toronto to Calgary
Driving 1899 5
india vs ire? and india vs south africa?
Sports 1792 2
US Education System
Have Fun! 1620 5
1st Test Day 3 - India vs South Africa Full Highlights
Sports 2476 0
Tendulkar wants to play 2011 World Cup when he will be 40?
General 1866 1
Return of few old Memory!
Sports 2249 1
IPL moved to South Africa
Sports 2548 4
Get together in Maple / Vaughan ( 1 2 3 )
Networking 4752 19
Sachin Vs Punter - Who is the best? ( 1 2 )
Sports 3436 9
T20 world cup - 2014 is for India this time or not? ( 1 2 )
Sports 2383 7
Jainna Patel a true agent of change !
Jobs 1657 0
need TN visa sponsor ship advise ( 1 2 )
Jobs 2764 11
 


Share:
















Advertise Contact Us Privacy Policy and Terms of Usage FAQ
Canadian Desi
© 2001 Marg eSolutions


Site designed, developed and maintained by Marg eSolutions Inc.