PR v/s Citizenship


Jump to Page:
< Previous  [ 1 ]  [ 2 ]  [ 3 ]    Next >



sukh   
Member since: Jun 04
Posts: 181
Location: Toronto ,Ontario

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 05-10-04 16:46:57

Hi Kamalrina,

I think bighead explained it very well, but if you are still confused let me try to explain again

Residency period is counted in 2 different ways:

1. If landing occurred less than 5 years ago then first 5 years period it is
counted 5 years forward from the day of landing

2. If landing occurred more than 5 years ago then 5 years period is counted
backwards - 5 years back from the day counting is being made (examination at the port of entry, application for Travel Document, application for PR Card or PR Card renewal, etc.).

This means your wife can enter LATEST by 11 July 2007 but KEEP IN MIND that she has to live continuously until 08 May 2009 to retain her PR.


-----------------------------------------------------------------
Sukhwinder Singh


Massood   
Member since: Dec 02
Posts: 1593
Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 05-10-04 20:06:30

I think enough has been said. I will refrain from commenting further.


-----------------------------------------------------------------
Massood Joomratty, LLB(Hons), LLM

http://www.passportcanada.com" target="_blank">Your Canadian Immigration Lawyer

http://www.joomratty.com" rel="nofollow">LINK
+1-604-590-0607


Ottawa_Nerd   
Member since: Jan 04
Posts: 1754
Location: Ottawa (Now in Bangalore)

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 07-10-04 01:48:17

Quote:
Orginally posted by bighead

the answer is b..

pr's need to accumilate 2 years of residence out of any 5 year block.. that means in any given 5 year period, you must reside in canada for 2 years... the confusion arises because people look at it from the other way around (by asking how long they can be absent)...

if you look at requirement for residency rather than how long you can dissapear, it seems a little clearer.. in any 5 year period, you must reside in canada for 2 in order to maintain pr status...

in your example, the 5 year block starts from jan 1st of year 1... if the person leaves on jan 1 of year 3 (with 2 years of residence) then in order to maintain pr he must return by dec 31 of year 5 (three years since leaving)... that does not mean a new 5 year block starts the day he returns, rather what you have to do is pick that day, count back 5 years from that day, and to maintain pr, you must have resided for 2 years from that day... in your example, on the day he returns (dec 31 year 5), if he counts back 5 years, he has two years of residency (hence satisfying requirement) but if he turns around and leaves on jan 2nd year 6, then on jan 3rd counting back 5 years, he will be two days short of pr requirement... (these numbers are illustrative only, things like leap years etc are not taken into account)...

same is true for citizenship as well... in the 4 year period the day before you apply to become a canadian citizen, you need 3 years of residency...



Bighead, please be kind enough to answer my choice also.. Is it a.) or b.) in my post ?


-----------------------------------------------------------------
"Aur Vaise Bhi, Sharafat ki jab kapde utarti hai, sabse zyaada mazaa shareefon ko hi aati hai"....(From The Dirty Picture)

Warning !! SCAM ALERT !!
http://www.canadiandesi.ca/read.php?TID=4169 & http://www.canadiandesi.ca/read.php?TID=1379
This is a Useful Health related Tip
http://www.canadiandesi.ca/read.php?TID=3865
Please visit
http://www.cmje.org/religious-texts/quran/verses/009-qmt.php for some interesting Information ! (Especially 009.005 )


bighead   
Member since: Jun 04
Posts: 285
Location:

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 07-10-04 15:29:05

ON, the answer in your scenario is a... it is easier if you first count back from the date of application and then count forward the number of days of residence...

1. pick the date when the person will apply...

2. count back 4 years from that date to arrive at the begining of the 4 year block... if the begining of the 4 years is before landing, then use the date of landing as the begining of the block... else use the date of the begining of the 4 year block...

3. count forward the number of days of residence between the start of the block to the date of application...

4. if you had legal status and residence between date of start of 4 year block calculated in 2 above, and date of landing, add number of days of residence between start of block and date of landing, and divide by 2... this cannot be greater than 365...

5. add 3 and 4... if that number is greater than or equal to 1095, then requirement has been met...

in your example 1:
point 1 = Oct 4, 2007
point 2 = Oct 4, 2004
point 3 = 1095
point 4 = 0
point 5 = 1095 + 0 = 1095 - requirement met

your example 2a:
point 1 = March 3rd 2008
point 2 = Oct 4, 2004
point 3 = 1095
point 4 = 0
point 5 = 1095 + 0 = 1095 - requirement met

BUT if he leaves for 6 months, comes back and applies on the same date
point 1 = Oct 4, 2007
point 2 = Oct 4, 2004
point 3 = 913
point 4 = 0
point 5 = 913 + 0 = 913 - requirement NOT met




bighead   
Member since: Jun 04
Posts: 285
Location:

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 07-10-04 19:27:23

someone pm-ed me with their scenario, and in the hope that it will clear a little more confusion, i will post the answer here... the dates have been offset a little bit for the person's privacy...

the person came to canada on july 13 2000 on a work permit...

the person applied for pr to buffalo (dates are not importat)

the person and his family took a trip to india for three weeks (21 days exactly) on March 2 2001, and returned on March 23 2001...

the person got his pr and officially became a landed immigrant of canada on september 28 2002...

after getting pr, the person has not left canada...

calculations based on points above...

point 1. suppose the person wanted to see if he would be eligible on Dec 6th 2004... lets say Dec 6 2004 is the date picked for point 1...

point 2. counting back 4 years puts us at Dec 6 2000 as the begining of the 4 year block... since this date is before landing, we use the date of landing (Sep 28 2002) as our starting point...

point 3. number of days of residence between landing and application minus one day = 799 days...

point 4. since the person was here on a wp, days before the landing may be included as half days (but only to a max of 2 years prior to landing - so from Sep 28 2000), so eligible days before landing = 730 (which is max) - 21 absent days /2 = 354.5 days...

point 5. 354.5 + 799 = 1153.5 days of eligible residence...

hence on Dec 6 2004, the person is eligible to apply for citizenship...

NOW, if you count backwards, the person has 58.5 days of residence more than the minimum requirement, so based on calendar days, the person became eligible for citizenship on Oct 9, 2004...



sukh   
Member since: Jun 04
Posts: 181
Location: Toronto ,Ontario

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 07-10-04 20:55:30

hi Bighead,

not to nit pick , as you are really working hard on this matter ...let us calculate again and see

if you take oct 9, 2004 then:

time spent as PR = 365+366+12 = 743

( sep 28-02 -- sep 27-03 + sep 28,03--sep 27, 04 + sep 28--oct 9 )

time spent on WP= 718-20 = 698/2 = 349

( half day spend in Canada is counted is day spent in Canada so he was out for only 20 days ? )

total becomes 1092 ..short by 3 days, eh ?

But according to my calculation he would be eligible on oct 15, 2004

time spent as PR = 365+366+18 = 749
time spent on WP= 712-20 = 692/2 = 346

total 1095 days

but I think it's easier to wait couple of days extra before applying :)



-----------------------------------------------------------------
Sukhwinder Singh


Mohanjeet   
Member since: Feb 04
Posts: 281
Location: Brampton

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 08-10-04 07:49:59

Can we also add up dys spend on tourist visa also before becoming Landed immigrant.



Contributors: bighead(6) Mohanjeet(4) sukh(2) Ottawa_Nerd(2) kamalraina(1) rajcanada(1) Massood(1) ashish30(1) chandresh(1)



Jump to Page: < Previous  [ 1 ]  [ 2 ]  [ 3 ]    Next >

Discussions similar to: PR v/s Citizenship

Topic Forum Views Replies
Minimum Stay to maintain P.R. Status ( 1 2 )
Ask Immigration Expert 4505 8
Want to Delay Lading
Independent Category 1725 3
730 Days = Two Years?????????????
Independent Category 1529 3
Social Housing and sponsorship
Family Class 1378 0
Mr Massood / Mr Khoslaw (Social Housing and sponsorship)
Ask Immigration Expert 1378 0
Information for Canadian Visa
Ask Immigration Expert 1628 3
Can I apply for citizenship??
Business 1911 6
landing in November
Moving Soon 2122 5
HOW SOON CAN I RETURN AND COME BACK TO CANADA AFTER LANDING?
Moving Soon 3833 6
Eligibility for Citizenship Applications ( 1 2 )
Citizenship 3374 10
Port of Entry Delays/Troubles
Just Landed 1422 1
seeking clarification on continuing PR status of my family
Life 1463 2
stayed over 3 years out of 5 years period
Ask Immigration Expert 1629 6
PR CARD AND CONFUSING ISSUES
Where to settle 1822 1
PR CARD AND CONFUSING ISSUES
Moving Soon 1640 3
Specific Permanent Residency Rules for Immigrants from India.
Moving Soon 1476 1
Reply
Moving Soon 1622 1
Citizenship
Ask Immigration Expert 1296 0
will workpermit period counts for residence claim for citizenship
Citizenship 1570 2
PR Card Renewal Question ( 1 2 3 )
Ask Immigration Expert 4918 14
Immigration related questions - Please help.
Ask Immigration Expert 1518 3
New Proposed Citizenship Law - Bill Being tabled in Parliament today ( 1 2 3 )
Citizenship 5873 19
IMM 008 Help Needed for counting Education Years
Study 1620 3
Mortgage : 5Y : 2.35F vs 2.10V ( 1 2 )
Real Estate & Mortgages 2730 10
 


Share:
















Advertise Contact Us Privacy Policy and Terms of Usage FAQ
Canadian Desi
© 2001 Marg eSolutions


Site designed, developed and maintained by Marg eSolutions Inc.